30 Rock 萌萌霸道總裁Alex 黑客軍團(tuán) 幻影老爹 Slate 再加 Fringe 神劇男主 神仙組合預(yù)告片一秒拉我入坑。。。。。。The scene in the room like slaughter house…… based on truth story….the puzzle remains : how a man getting out of prestigious medical program, prestigious residency , gaining numerous prestigious scores, having such heinous performance in practice and getting away (╯°□°）╯︵ ┻━┻ two of his colleagues trying to figure out, gathering evidence and reporting their findings to Texas Medical Board

鄒波

死亡醫(yī)生里庭審自相矛盾的地方：出于正義的目的，為了讓死亡醫(yī)生終身監(jiān)禁不再有任何機(jī)會(huì)害人，檢方必須證明該醫(yī)生是故意殺人，而不是被系統(tǒng)腐敗寵溺的外科醫(yī)生里的“熊孩子”（在一個(gè)復(fù)雜的法律體系里，卻只有一種奇怪的非黑即白），必須證明這個(gè)死亡醫(yī)生手術(shù)致死三十三個(gè)人，是出于他的自我（我對(duì)這一命題的解釋是：還用“專門去作惡?jiǎn)?？”——一個(gè)人如果一天二十四小時(shí)每分每秒都自負(fù)都傲慢都自以為是，如果他在任何大小事情和細(xì)節(jié)里都忠于他的自負(fù)和權(quán)力的傲慢，他就自動(dòng)相當(dāng)于一個(gè)故意草菅人命的人），而非醫(yī)療界系統(tǒng)性的腐敗導(dǎo)致對(duì)一個(gè)沒(méi)有自我意識(shí)的人的縱容，但持有這一觀點(diǎn)的檢察官繼續(xù)說(shuō)出了她不自知的自相矛盾：如果陪審團(tuán)今天不去阻止，這個(gè)醫(yī)生會(huì)繼續(xù)行醫(yī)。那么，她聲稱的陪審團(tuán)本身的決定權(quán)就已經(jīng)說(shuō)明了這種系統(tǒng)性縱容的決定性。那么，回過(guò)頭來(lái)，總的來(lái)說(shuō)，還是系統(tǒng)性的腐敗決定了一切，而且，系統(tǒng)性腐敗是乖巧的，靈巧的，總是在空出一個(gè)壞人的形象。

7/22/2021 一下午刷完 很多感想 憑我多年看劇經(jīng)驗(yàn) 這部劇弱在開(kāi)頭了 題材很好 切入點(diǎn)也很好 結(jié)構(gòu)完整 表達(dá)清晰 鏡頭語(yǔ)言也算到位 中規(guī)中矩 沒(méi)有特別驚艷也并不出格 但不好的地方在于多線程敘事的開(kāi)頭做得太弱了 時(shí)間太混亂 沒(méi)有一個(gè)清晰的 引人注目的點(diǎn) 我前四集都是暈著看的 經(jīng)常弄不清楚目前這段兒講的是啥時(shí)候的事 而且所鋪設(shè)的伏筆真的太小了 沒(méi)耐心看下去的人就特別容易錯(cuò)過(guò) 這么低的豆瓣評(píng)分 我差一丁點(diǎn)兒就也要棄劇了 還是故事本身太過(guò)令人震驚 那可真尼瑪震驚 越往下看越覺(jué)得渾身冒冷汗.. 大概看了下短評(píng) 竟然不少人差評(píng)原因是為主角洗白 我手動(dòng)黑人問(wèn)號(hào)臉！ 整個(gè)劇看下來(lái)只會(huì)覺(jué)得主角恐怖地很 完全缺乏共情 職場(chǎng)/戀愛(ài)PUA達(dá)人 低氣壓營(yíng)造者 后幾集我冷汗都沒(méi)停過(guò) 竟然有人說(shuō)洗白男主 再次手動(dòng)黑人問(wèn)號(hào)..

認(rèn)真看的同學(xué)們都能看出來(lái) 劇中提到的幾個(gè)醫(yī)院 特別是貝勒 絕對(duì)有不可推卸的責(zé)任 而且ASA的辯論最后陳詞其實(shí)特別好 這個(gè)證明意圖的方法我沒(méi)想到 辯護(hù)方顯然也沒(méi)想到 而且我大概查了一下 這個(gè)案子是此類案子的先例 對(duì)以后的判定都有指導(dǎo)意義 這也是這部劇精彩的一段

三個(gè)老戲骨表現(xiàn)不錯(cuò) 男主估計(jì)今晚會(huì)出現(xiàn)在我噩夢(mèng)中?? baldwin最后那段陳詞十分很給力 Slater吐槽真心幫觀眾疏解情緒 幾個(gè)我不太認(rèn)識(shí)的配角也都不錯(cuò) summers 實(shí)慘 還有 男主他爸 沒(méi)出場(chǎng)幾分鐘 卻讓我印象深刻 別的患者們 我天…每每看到他們躺病床上被推進(jìn)去 都尼瑪揪心..

整體來(lái)說(shuō) 我還是會(huì)推薦給我的朋友們的 家父就是外科大夫 耳濡目染 我也能感受到當(dāng)外科大夫所需要的精力體力和手上功夫（他跟我媽結(jié)婚時(shí)的家具都是自己做的！）所以看這個(gè)劇經(jīng)常會(huì)發(fā)出 wc fk等不和諧音 震驚到我了 我知道我以后都不會(huì)再是之前的我了 我以后在美國(guó)看大夫 一定會(huì)先刨根挖底一番??

記得看完《大白鯊》之后很久都對(duì)海灘有恐懼感。這部《死亡醫(yī)生》也有類似的觀感，一直在尋思以后不要看醫(yī)生了，退一步又想干脆還是不要生病了——盡管理性告訴自己這樣的醫(yī)生并不多見(jiàn)（貶義）。

《死亡醫(yī)生》不是恐怖片，沒(méi)有諸如尖叫或陰森的音樂(lè)等傳統(tǒng)恐怖元素，主角甚至多數(shù)時(shí)候都是笑容可掬，但是觀看過(guò)程卻一直覺(jué)得后背發(fā)涼；主創(chuàng)也無(wú)意將它做成懸疑劇，事情明擺在那里了，主要講述兩個(gè)好醫(yī)生，亨德森和科比，還有一個(gè)年輕的檢察官在扳倒壞醫(yī)生鄧奇的路上所遇到的種種阻礙，揭露惡魔的同時(shí)抨擊僵化的體制；謝天謝地它不是心理探索劇，后面Ebert的劇評(píng)里也講到了這一點(diǎn)，用不著找原因替惡魔開(kāi)脫。

本劇將死于醫(yī)生的患者數(shù)據(jù)通過(guò)具體的人表現(xiàn)出來(lái)，因?yàn)榭赡馨l(fā)生在每個(gè)人身上，所以更容易引起共鳴。

第四集臨結(jié)尾兩個(gè)好醫(yī)生找到檢察官，舒加特女士有過(guò)好幾次特寫鏡頭，就猜到下半場(chǎng)大概率以她為主導(dǎo)，從醫(yī)學(xué)調(diào)查轉(zhuǎn)入訴訟，刑事調(diào)查不是重點(diǎn)，關(guān)鍵是如何有效立案，給死亡醫(yī)生最重的處罰。

舒加特女士所問(wèn)的，也是在看劇過(guò)程中我一直想問(wèn)的，一個(gè)做事如此不周密的人是如何一步一步成為主刀醫(yī)生的——《實(shí)習(xí)醫(yī)生格蕾》等劇中的小大夫想得到手術(shù)機(jī)會(huì)都要明爭(zhēng)暗搶機(jī)關(guān)算盡，而鄧奇輕而易舉就拿到了刀。手術(shù)室政治讓巡回護(hù)士、X線技師等面對(duì)他的屠夫行為敢怒不敢言；類似貝勒等醫(yī)療機(jī)構(gòu)的逐利之心蒙蔽了監(jiān)管層的雙眼；冗長(zhǎng)的司法過(guò)程讓受害者退卻，劇中提到過(guò)即使贏了也只有25萬(wàn)的賠償，律師不可以分這種錢，意味著沒(méi)人愿意接類似官司。

當(dāng)舒加特女士初見(jiàn)兩位好醫(yī)生時(shí)，他們因?yàn)樗哪贻p而受到了冒犯，覺(jué)得地區(qū)檢察官不夠重視。舒加特女士自己也說(shuō)：”對(duì)你們來(lái)說(shuō)我可能是too young too woman“。

我想鄧奇能夠很容易得到別人的信任，他白人男性的身份幫助不小。換個(gè)膚色換個(gè)性別可能就行不通了。

第五集手術(shù)之后，同臺(tái)的醫(yī)生直面鄧奇，譴責(zé)他不是醫(yī)生是屠夫。鄧奇居然笑了出來(lái)。

豆瓣簡(jiǎn)介里說(shuō)男主“聰明有魅力”，說(shuō)實(shí)話我沒(méi)發(fā)現(xiàn)鄧奇此人有任何優(yōu)點(diǎn)。嗑藥酗酒謊話連篇，連基本的生活能力都沒(méi)有，鑰匙經(jīng)常性忘記在門上；從年輕時(shí)打橄欖球開(kāi)始就分不清楚左和右，這個(gè)問(wèn)題一直到手術(shù)時(shí)還存在；第五集他沒(méi)有辦法安裝好嬰兒床，而他的解決辦法是指責(zé)一旁打下手的溫迪，最后一跑了之。之前某集科比醫(yī)生形容他的手術(shù)，”就像安裝宜家的東西，安完后發(fā)現(xiàn)還有一袋螺絲（沒(méi)用上）“，是嬰兒床一幕的伏筆吧。

鄧奇對(duì)待他的每個(gè)病人，就像渣男對(duì)待每個(gè)女人，開(kāi)始時(shí)甜言蜜語(yǔ)、殷勤備至，得手后立刻換一副嘴臉。只不過(guò)鄧特的得手，是奪走別人正常生活的能力甚至生命。他對(duì)自己孩子的母親溫迪和好友杰瑞也是一樣，用后即棄。在拋棄過(guò)程中他表現(xiàn)出來(lái)的厭惡和嫌棄真是太讓人心寒以及惡心了。

只有Kim Morgan很快發(fā)現(xiàn)了鄧奇的真面目，然后果斷離開(kāi)。確實(shí)是聰明的女人，面試時(shí)就指出鄧奇診所的種種問(wèn)題。演員Grace Gummer，以前看過(guò)她的《醫(yī)緣》，是很有潛力的演員，這次《死亡醫(yī)生》比《醫(yī)緣》表現(xiàn)更好。不得不提一句（Grace本人可能不喜歡這樣介紹啦），她的母親是赫赫有名的梅麗爾-斯特里普，仔細(xì)看眉眼還挺像呢?！靖貉荨夺t(yī)緣》（Emily Owens M.D.）的，不是Grace，而是斯特里普的另一個(gè)女兒麥米-古默，Mamie還在《基本演繹法》S3E6演過(guò)兇手。姐妹倆長(zhǎng)得很像。Grace的代表作是《美國(guó)恐怖故事》等】

鄧奇給Kim的這封電子郵件會(huì)起關(guān)鍵作用吧？這么明確地表示自己就是個(gè)冷血?dú)⑹趾头瓷鐣?huì)。這部劇目前還沒(méi)看到浪費(fèi)的鏡頭或臺(tái)詞，鄧特辦公室里有一個(gè)壞了的燈曾經(jīng)有人問(wèn)起過(guò)，鄧特以自己舞技不好支支吾吾，幾集之后劇里交待了壞的原因。

第六集打電話騙老爸的錢，電話亭旁邊有骷髏的涂鴉。很有心的鏡頭。

Roger Ebert關(guān)于《死亡醫(yī)生》的評(píng)論

原作者是Ebert團(tuán)隊(duì)的Brian Tallerico，國(guó)外的專業(yè)影評(píng)人是看到全部八集以后寫的評(píng)論，給了3/4的評(píng)分?！尽?jī)?nèi)是我的想法，不是翻譯。

Peacock’s intelligent and gripping “Dr. Death,” based on the podcast of the same name, avoids the pitfalls of many true crime narratives, smartly realizing that a monster like Christopher Duntsch can’t be explained in an eight-episode mini-series. I have a strong aversion to projects about sociopaths that attempt to explain them away via abusive pasts or other supposed “reasons” for their actions. Those ideas proliferate because of a human need to try and compartmentalize evil, but men like Chris Duntsch can’t be so easily explained, and this series about his rise and fall understands that. With excellent performances and a procedural tone that interrogates an entire system instead of just one man, “Dr. Death” is a solid drama about a man who thought he could play God but never realized he wasn’t talented or smart enough to do so.

【intelligent，gripping，smartly，excellent performance，solid drama，極盡贊美之詞。明確表示自己不喜歡心理探索，給惡魔人性化的描寫，或者給他一個(gè)被虐待的童年什么的，完全用不著。這段也承認(rèn)八集是寫不明白男主這樣的惡魔的，他就是一個(gè)想扮演上帝的人，卻不夠聰明，也不夠有才華——如果先天不聰明，也可能通過(guò)后天的努力獲得才華，但鄧奇只想走捷徑?！?/p>

A rising star in the Dallas medical community, Christopher Duntsch (Joshua Jackson) promised life-changing procedures to his patients, most of whom came to him at the lowest points in their lives. He claimed to be a pioneer in stem cell research that would forever change those afflicted with spinal issues, and his neurosurgery practice seemed like it was on the rise when patients suddenly started coming out of his procedures maimed or worse. A neurosurgeon named Robert Henderson (Alec Baldwin) who was called in to clean up one of Duntsch’s botched surgeries realized the borderline insane situation with which he was dealing and aligned with a colleague named Randall Kirby (Christian Slater) to try and get Duntsch’s license taken away. As they investigated Duntsch’s many failures, they realized the depth of his depravity, and the whole thing turned into a legal case, led by a young Dallas prosecutor named Michelle Shugart (AnnaSophia Robb), who eventually prosecuted Duntsch in a precedent-setting trial.

【基本劇情介紹】

Created by Patrick Macmanus (“Homecoming”), “Dr. Death” jumps back and forth between the developing case—first focusing on Henderson/Kirby’s medical investigation and then the legal one with Shugart—and flashbacks to Duntsch’s procedures and personal life. The show opens with disclaimers about some names and facts changed for fiction’s sake, but the version of Duntsch here is a vile user, someone who discarded not just patients but everyone who helped him along the way, including his son’s mother (Molly Griggs). Even Duntsch's best friend Jerry (Dominic Burgess) ended up one of his victims after a spinal surgery paralyzed him. The portrait of Duntsch here is someone who impresses at first, especially those on hospital boards who might make money off a hotshot neurosurgeon, but whose fa?ade eventually crumbles, taking anyone around into the rubble. It certainly does for a confident physician’s assistant (an effective Grace Gummer), who sees firsthand the corners that Duntsch is willing to cut.

【這個(gè)版本的鄧特就是惡毒的利用者】

The flashbacks present a man who somehow thought he could push through any adversity. That’s one thing when you’re repeatedly getting a play wrong in a football practice, and quite another when you’re incapable of performing the spinal surgeries that you’ve promised your patients. And yet “Dr. Death” smartly never resorts to humanizing Duntsch, who sees his mistakes as mere common malpractice all the way up to the end. What’s so disturbing about this case is the idea, raised a few times here, that Duntsch must have known what he was doing in a few instances. Is it possible he was a literal sociopath and maimed his patients on purpose? Dr. Henderson sure seems to think so as he explains how the violence from Duntsch’s surgeries would be hard to call accidental. It sounds like even someone who had never performed a surgery would know that they were doing something very wrong. Did Duntsch? Did he just not care? We'll never know, and "Dr. Death" wisely only hints at these darker themes instead of turning into melodrama. It makes them all the more terrifying.

【閃回中的橄欖球訓(xùn)練，就像以后一次次的手術(shù)，鄧特以為他能推開(kāi)各種阻礙。然而一次一次犯錯(cuò)，球賽中和手術(shù)臺(tái)上所造成的后果完全不一樣。這段又用wisely形容這部劇?！?/p>

The generally underrated Joshua Jackson carries “Dr. Death” with a fascinating blend of idiotic confidence and nonchalant sociopathology. He nails the ego that often hides incompetence, embodying a person who thinks he can merely work around inadequacy. We’ve all met men like Chris Duntsch—people that think if they tell themselves that they can change the world that it will somehow be true. What separates this story is that most of those people get shot down before they can do real harm, but Duntsch was enabled again and again. There’s a fascinating undercurrent to “Dr. Death” that reminded me of “Spotlight,” another story of vile predators who were moved around a broken system instead of brought to justice. Duntsch was allowed to perform dozens of life-changing bad surgeries and even killed a couple people before upstanding fellow surgeons took him down.

【Joshua Jackson這個(gè)演員確實(shí)不錯(cuò)。這部劇讓劇評(píng)作者聯(lián)想到《聚焦》，都是在潰爛的體制中橫行的惡魔?！?/p>

The whole cast matches Jackson’s nuance, especially Slater and Baldwin. It’s particularly rewarding to see the latter get a subtle, complex role for the first time in what feels like a long time—there’s a quiet fury and professional disgust to his performance that’s admirable. And Slater balances him nicely with a more brash, outgoing performance so the two don’t feel like the same character. Robb is definitely good, but I’ll admit to liking the first half of the season more when Baldwin/Slater were driving the investigation instead of the legal hotshot. The transition leads to a bit of a drag in the middle of the season and I’d be remiss if I didn’t mention the fat suit prosthetics that Jackson is forced to act through in the last couple episodes, which are a drastic misfire. Each episode opens with the disclaimer that some of the truth has been bent, and I get that the fat suit is meant to further represent Duntsch’s decline, but it’s just distracting.

【其他演員也相當(dāng)優(yōu)秀?？吹降诹胖肋@里的“fat suit”是什么意思，鄧特開(kāi)始發(fā)胖了，所以演員穿了fat suit，象征著鄧特“光輝歲月”的終結(jié)，但劇評(píng)作者不太喜歡這個(gè)安排，讓他出戲，我覺(jué)得還好啦。另外說(shuō)明一點(diǎn)的是，戒酒的人血糖會(huì)低，所以他們都會(huì)大量吃糖或巧克力等補(bǔ)充糖分。第六集鄧特在爸爸家里喝咖啡瘋狂放糖。】

Finally, it’s important to note that “Dr. Death” never feels sensational or exploitative, expressing the empathy for Duntsch’s victims he so clearly lacked. It’s ultimately a castigation of a system that values profits over professionalism, and tells young upstarts like Duntsch that they'll be the faces of a medical revolution before asking if the person with the scalpel is at all capable of leading the way.

【還是，動(dòng)手術(shù)前想想拿刀的人是誰(shuí)?！?/p>

寫完了，最后兩集還沒(méi)更新，繼續(xù)等~~

第七集，手術(shù)服褲子上的洞原來(lái)是這么來(lái)的~~

科比和亨德森兩個(gè)醫(yī)生性格互補(bǔ)，一個(gè)沉穩(wěn)，一個(gè)外向略暴躁?？票仍谏钌喜痪行」?jié)，之前某集把腳丫蹺到亨德森的辦公桌上；這集又瞎說(shuō)俄語(yǔ)，“達(dá)斯維達(dá)尼亞”是再見(jiàn)的意思，他用來(lái)打招呼。哈哈哈哈，太可愛(ài)了。

兩個(gè)好醫(yī)生都襯托了鄧奇的惡。亨德森說(shuō)過(guò)，失去過(guò)一個(gè)患者，一直讓他耿耿于懷，庭審時(shí)也說(shuō)他哪怕有過(guò)鄧奇33例手術(shù)中的一例結(jié)果，也不會(huì)再進(jìn)手術(shù)室?？票入m然生活中大大咧咧，但專業(yè)上極認(rèn)真。正是有這樣的好醫(yī)生，我們才能放心地去海灘，哦不是，去醫(yī)院看病，信任醫(yī)生。

其他配角也都映襯了男主，聽(tīng)完鄧奇說(shuō)話之后覺(jué)得每個(gè)人說(shuō)話都非常讓人舒服。甚至他的律師，思維和談吐都遠(yuǎn)遠(yuǎn)好過(guò)鄧奇本人，能想到把責(zé)任推到大學(xué)和各級(jí)培訓(xùn)醫(yī)院，也是相當(dāng)敬業(yè)的律師。而舒加特這一方贏得坦蕩蕩，沒(méi)有使詐。特別喜歡法庭戲上他們用排比句。亨德森背誦希波克拉底誓言一段太熱血了。

Kim拿槍逼退鄧奇的樣子簡(jiǎn)直太帥了。廣大年輕女孩應(yīng)該以此為榜樣，正確面對(duì)感情中的失敗，遇上人渣不是你們的錯(cuò)，果斷離開(kāi)是正確選擇。生命太短，容不得猶豫和反復(fù)。提高生命效率啊朋友們！

杰瑞-薩默斯就執(zhí)迷不悟，是Kim的對(duì)比。

人物包括每個(gè)患者及家屬都各有特色，雖然角色也不少，但看完以后都?xì)v歷在目的感覺(jué)。Beyer夫人出場(chǎng)時(shí)我還記得她第一次說(shuō)自己名字的發(fā)音，“象那種動(dòng)物”。去世的Brennan夫人，受傷僅僅是裝飾圣誕樹(shù)時(shí)腳下的一個(gè)不穩(wěn)。每個(gè)角色都塑造得很成功。

保護(hù)患者，健全體制。

任重而道遠(yuǎn)。

該劇改編自真實(shí)案件，講述反社會(huì)人格的醫(yī)生，開(kāi)篇賺足噱頭，往后又涉及到美國(guó)醫(yī)療體系、司法體系的社會(huì)弊端，很有現(xiàn)實(shí)意義，另外選角方面更是極具舒適度?？傮w絕對(duì)在水準(zhǔn)之上的，劇荒下飯可。

局限在于個(gè)別人物前后矛盾的態(tài)度及其轉(zhuǎn)變?cè)驔](méi)有交代清楚。所以個(gè)人認(rèn)為在故事敘述完成度上來(lái)說(shuō)，八集短了點(diǎn)，評(píng)論區(qū)大多不滿在于覺(jué)得劇情拖沓，嫌棄壞人逍遙法外太久，雖然我也深有同感，但老實(shí)講，支線劇情也算不上無(wú)聊或者說(shuō)“水”。導(dǎo)演沒(méi)有過(guò)多停留在受害者苦難處來(lái)制造煽情，而是將主要篇幅用在對(duì)醫(yī)生的人物刻畫、背景交代，而這些又是很必要的。

所以觀感上的冗長(zhǎng)大概主要怪原型人物太差勁，引不起觀眾興趣；其次導(dǎo)演編劇沒(méi)能抓住觀眾想看的點(diǎn)，比如我比較期待兩位偵探醫(yī)生，萌妹檢察官等高光人物的展開(kāi)，又或關(guān)于善良無(wú)辜受害者的細(xì)節(jié)，以及屠夫醫(yī)生這么做的自白等等。最后，第八集的法庭環(huán)節(jié)還是蠻多精彩之處的，該劇至少7.5以上比較合理啦~

最后最后，原來(lái)Kim和傲骨賢妻里的律師真的是姐妹阿omg