前言

起筆于 02:20 23/12/2021 愛丁堡

701小時(shí)玩家

想了很久，我決定還是寫一下我對(duì)于獵魔人第二季看完后的看法。作為上一篇觀后感還是在小學(xué)為了應(yīng)付老師而寫的刻板理科生?；谖覍?duì)于獵魔人游戲和原著的熱愛，我決定盡我所能寫下我對(duì)于這部劇的看法。為了讓大家能夠抓住重點(diǎn)，我會(huì)盡量用寫程序報(bào)告的寫法來羅列重點(diǎn)。 我先說下我和獵魔人的緣分，我是游玩了巫師3以后才對(duì)原著有了巨大的愛好然后購置了獵魔人系列的小說，基于我對(duì)于原著語言波蘭語的有限了解，我有幸閱讀了由重慶出版社翻譯出版的中文版本。所以我接下來對(duì)于劇情的評(píng)價(jià)將基于我從漢語譯本內(nèi)容的理解。

作為一名資深的葉奈法黨，當(dāng)她在白果園從眾多尼弗迦德士兵中走向杰洛特的時(shí)候。我就被她的美貌所深深的吸引。后來更是在原著中被她和杰洛特復(fù)雜的羈絆而深深的著迷。無論是葉奈法在關(guān)于希瑞在教育問題上因?yàn)榻苈逄亍坝H愛的朋友”起頭而在信件中充滿怨念的拌嘴，還是杰洛特在迷霧中拜訪索登山烈士墓那端內(nèi)心獨(dú)白的震撼。都能充分理解為什么在巫師3中最后的愿望葉奈法聽到杰洛特告白時(shí)那含情脈脈眼神亦或看到最后杰洛特和葉奈法在陶森特?fù)碛凶约喊诪貘f莊園時(shí)那種童話成真的感覺--------------那正是葉奈法在阿瑞圖扎時(shí)向杰洛特喃喃的那最真誠的愿望（劇透了，但沒完全劇透）

本著對(duì)于葉奈法的喜愛，我會(huì)優(yōu)先以葉奈法劇情方面來帶入我對(duì)于劇情的部分想法。

關(guān)于劇情和原著上面的差別

在這里我推薦一個(gè)經(jīng)過葉奈法吧大神翻譯過的波蘭廣播劇中關(guān)于葉奈法和杰洛特的劇情，接下來我都會(huì)把片段的時(shí)間貼出來來給大家感受原著的劇情。

//www.bilibili.com/video/BV1Mx411t7wt?from=search&seid=14212587872411211060&spm_id_from=333.337.0.0

我會(huì)貼出關(guān)于他們劇情對(duì)應(yīng)廣播劇中的部分，要想了解杰洛特和葉奈法，其實(shí)僅僅用這個(gè)視頻，幾乎能夠涵蓋小說大部分他們之間的感情戲。在這里我僅僅貼出第二季和小說中重疊的時(shí)間線，在杰洛特和葉奈法通信后的部分要在后面幾季體現(xiàn)，最后一部分是 葉 黨 狂 喜 的同人部分??！

前面是最后的愿望和可能的極限，第一部劇破壞的不算嚴(yán)重，這里我就不多贅述了。

冰之碎片（11:55）：

- 這段算是葉奈法和杰洛特一起時(shí)秀恩愛的部分

- 也是小說中伊斯崔德認(rèn)識(shí)杰洛特的章節(jié)

比那更多（25:12）：

- 五月節(jié)杰洛特約的時(shí)候遇到了正在約的葉奈法

- 這也是葉奈法告訴杰洛特要尋找比迪精更多的東西來維系他們的感情

- 嗯是的和電視劇相反

第十四個(gè)名字（35:20）：

- 杰洛特在索登山上看著烈士墓時(shí)的內(nèi)心獨(dú)白

- 杰洛特開始一個(gè)一個(gè)讀著陣亡者以及對(duì)其他陣亡者背景的補(bǔ)充 37:31

- 當(dāng)杰洛特不敢讀最后一個(gè)因?yàn)樗嘈拍鞘侨~奈法以及高潮部分 38:46

杰洛特和葉奈法在信件中討論關(guān)于希瑞的教育（47:06）：

- 前面還有一個(gè)杰洛特和小屁孩的對(duì)話，非常有趣地展現(xiàn)了杰洛特的性格2333333

- 希瑞寄給杰洛特的信 48:53，

- 年輕時(shí)候萌萌的希瑞哈哈哈，劇里面看不到

- 葉奈法送來的信 54:37

- 毒舌和傲嬌盡顯無疑wwwww

可以說我對(duì)于這部電視劇最復(fù)雜的態(tài)度就是對(duì)于葉奈法的刻畫，因?yàn)槌怂渌膭∏槲叶寄芙⒆銐虻男膽B(tài)去接受，但我這里盡量用不帶主觀態(tài)度去說下第二季對(duì)于葉奈法內(nèi)容的編纂，盡量不去涉及抽象評(píng)價(jià)這種玩意。

伊斯崔德

首先，和伊斯崔德相關(guān)的劇情其實(shí)在小說中僅限在冰之碎片里面。在電視劇中我可以理解他推動(dòng)了部分劇情以及背景的補(bǔ)充。我覺得在小說中是著重于對(duì)葉奈法和杰洛特感情線的補(bǔ)充，為了理解日后杰洛特和葉奈法之間那奇妙命運(yùn)的鋪墊。但是在電視劇中，仿佛制作人要給予他更多的工具人角色，他所研究的巨石陣在原著小說不存在，但我覺得是個(gè)對(duì)于希瑞能力視覺效果更好的補(bǔ)充，所以可以理解。電視劇中冰之碎片根本不存在，所以我就勉強(qiáng)接受了這兩人認(rèn)識(shí)的奇妙場合，畢竟杰洛特就是不相信命運(yùn)卻充滿了命運(yùn)相遇的天選之子，所以真巧對(duì)杰洛特來說就是家常便飯哈哈哈。

以葉奈法與希瑞導(dǎo)入我看希瑞劇情的態(tài)度

希瑞與葉奈法的劇情因?yàn)閻耗∏榈牟迦氡环至训钠扑榱芾?。我的想法可能覺得劇組為了吸引觀眾的注意加入了很多其他劇情的設(shè)定。這個(gè)惡魔的設(shè)定我看著竟然如此眼熟，想必可能和前段時(shí)間刷了康斯坦丁，驅(qū)魔人有關(guān)吧。本人靈魂被關(guān)在某個(gè)領(lǐng)域；仇恨會(huì)使惡魔力量強(qiáng)大；當(dāng)眾多驅(qū)魔人用愛感化的時(shí)候，我覺得就差一個(gè)十字架和“上帝愛你”了。題外話，感覺惡魔本身設(shè)定感覺和巫師3中惡靈纏身任務(wù)中的希姆也有那么點(diǎn)相似。

其實(shí)杰洛特邀請(qǐng)葉奈法之前已經(jīng)請(qǐng)?zhí)乩蚪z來幫希瑞，原因也是某些和葉奈法斗氣的原因所以不請(qǐng)葉奈法，后來特莉絲表示自己不行直接讓葉奈法來看看。這種尷尬的場面配上后來杰洛特對(duì)于葉奈法錯(cuò)誤的稱呼“親愛的朋友”。導(dǎo)致葉奈法那種怒氣已經(jīng)躍然紙上，在小說中這段也是對(duì)于杰洛特和葉奈法感情線的補(bǔ)充。

由于惡魔劇情的加入，所以第二季并沒有對(duì)于葉奈法教導(dǎo)希瑞的大部分描寫。但是為了推進(jìn)葉奈法受到惡魔蠱惑那部分，零零碎碎有了些對(duì)于希瑞的教導(dǎo)，因?yàn)槿~奈法在電視劇中失去了魔力。在小說中希瑞學(xué)習(xí)法術(shù)比電視劇中要難很多，這個(gè)過程和第一季中葉奈法學(xué)習(xí)法術(shù)過程差不多，而且其實(shí)葉奈法教導(dǎo)希瑞其實(shí)也和蒂莎婭教導(dǎo)葉奈法過程差不多，不乏嚴(yán)厲的教導(dǎo)以及溫柔的一面。于電視劇中堅(jiān)韌的希瑞，我覺得這更像小說后期的希瑞，小說早期的希瑞異常淘氣可愛，屢次因?yàn)榉ㄐg(shù)太難表示摸了摸了不學(xué)了，游戲里也有所體現(xiàn)，就是阿瓦拉克教導(dǎo)希瑞的時(shí)候希瑞覺得好難就不想學(xué)然后和杰洛特打雪球摸魚（大霧）。葉奈法有時(shí)毒嘴有時(shí)很溫柔。而那句對(duì)于杰洛特的評(píng)價(jià)，也是在葉奈法和希瑞關(guān)系非常親密的時(shí)候。葉奈法非常不情愿但又娓娓道來地告訴了希瑞，體現(xiàn)了自己對(duì)于和杰洛特之間羈絆的復(fù)雜的態(tài)度。而在電視劇里感覺就是為了原封不動(dòng)的念小說這部分臺(tái)詞。

既然之后有葉奈法教希瑞的戲份，希望第三季能夠好好再發(fā)展下她倆之間的母女情感發(fā)展www

杰洛特與葉奈法

我在小說中非常喜歡的部分，為了不褻瀆我最愛的部分，我僅僅寫簡短的不完整的感想來表達(dá)我對(duì)于第二季的態(tài)度，但這不代表我的完整的觀點(diǎn)。

其實(shí)小說中最主要的是，前面的短篇之間時(shí)間間隔非常大。比如在和三寒鴉告別后。葉奈法和杰洛特重歸于好以后，兩人一起去了很多地方。以我的理解，他們的這段情感線止于冰之碎片之后，兩人生活方式差距之大導(dǎo)致了很多問題，而又因?yàn)橐链匏沟聻楸l(fā)點(diǎn)。之后到某年五月節(jié)兩人再次相遇，并且葉奈法與杰洛特在短暫的歡愉后向杰洛特提出了那個(gè)愿望，那個(gè)能更緊密聯(lián)系他們命運(yùn)的存在。再之后其實(shí)兩人見面就在阿拉圖扎了那也應(yīng)該是電視劇線里第三季了。

被替代的內(nèi)容中，杰洛特在第十四個(gè)名字中的劇情在電視劇中被嫁接給了蒂瑞莎對(duì)于葉奈法的尋找，展現(xiàn)了蒂莎婭對(duì)于葉奈法的愛護(hù)?？梢哉f編劇成功讓小說的其他角色有了更多的戲份。

至于小說和電視劇兩人相處劇情的區(qū)別，我之前給的廣播劇已經(jīng)很能體現(xiàn)它們的區(qū)別。我就不多說了。

總的來說，電視劇讓我們更加容易理解葉奈法的性格，因?yàn)槎嗔藢?duì)葉奈法成長過程的講述。而在小說中只是最后的愿望中杰洛特注視著葉奈法的眼神中一帶而過葉奈法的過去。而對(duì)于兩人的感情也是依靠數(shù)篇短片小說有了逐漸立體的了解。

節(jié)奏的把控以及一些新劇情

獵魔人中出現(xiàn)了很多新的劇情，但是很容易看得出編劇借鑒了奈飛其他影視作品的理念。但是過程，更像是在流水線上生產(chǎn)的汽車上加上一些運(yùn)動(dòng)套件或者上個(gè)品牌音箱的做法。流行的劇情設(shè)計(jì)加上一些獵魔人世界觀的設(shè)計(jì)，比如我之前談及希瑞劇情時(shí)談到對(duì)于惡魔劇情的看法。

從積極的來說，小說本身的節(jié)奏和電視劇的節(jié)奏是不一樣的。運(yùn)用小說的節(jié)奏可能會(huì)讓電視劇本身失去吸引力。獵魔人小說中有大量對(duì)于杰洛特自己內(nèi)心想法的寫照，配合葉奈法本身會(huì)讀心的技術(shù)，通常會(huì)給劇情帶來很多意外的幽默。而之后希瑞等也會(huì)有心理描寫。這推進(jìn)了劇情的發(fā)展并且讓閱讀變得更加有趣。頗為玩味的是，小說很少涉及葉奈法心理的描寫，這樣就更加讓我們有一種基于杰洛特本身去揣測葉奈法想法的感覺，從而讓故事更有一種參與感？至少對(duì)我來說。

而這些在電視劇中是很難展現(xiàn)的，這很難依靠動(dòng)作來展現(xiàn)，用畫外音顯得非常突兀。所以我也可以理解編劇刪除了某些故事情節(jié)，就拿第十四個(gè)名字和冰之碎片，這兩篇對(duì)于杰洛特的心聲內(nèi)容的編寫非常之長。在電視劇的確有點(diǎn)難體現(xiàn)。其實(shí)在巫師3游戲里，很多依靠的是杰洛特的自言自語，所以玩家也能感受到很多時(shí)候白狼尖銳的吐槽。

以我的愚見，編劇是像融合奈飛元素和獵魔人小說的風(fēng)格。將獵魔人的故事至少是在奈飛電視劇上變得更加引人入勝。

戰(zhàn)斗

巫師系列游戲可以說，對(duì)于小說中戰(zhàn)斗元素方面有了繼承和發(fā)展。更不用說對(duì)于原來小說情節(jié)的尊重以及大膽做出的革新。而在電視劇中，很多戰(zhàn)斗元素也讓我這個(gè)游戲黨非常欣喜。包括阿爾德?lián)袈潺埡痛髴?zhàn)吸血鬼女部分還是非常喜歡的。大戰(zhàn)吸血鬼女讓我有種重溫難忘之夜的感覺

//www.bilibili.com/video/BV1Ko4y1o7Tf/?spm_id_from=333.788.recommend_more_video.0

特別是嗑了黑血那段還是很棒的，雖然貌似吸血妖女最后沒有吸黑血？不過火焰劍這個(gè)還是第一次見。

結(jié)語 tucao

讓我熬夜寫下這篇漏洞百出文章的是某位五星評(píng)論對(duì)原著黨和游戲黨隔空輸出的評(píng)論員，打著“高抬貴手”的說法卻充滿了對(duì)原著黨和游戲黨的偏見和輕蔑。雖然我承認(rèn)評(píng)論區(qū)充滿了大家片片斷斷的差評(píng)或者是吐槽，但是您對(duì)于獵魔人系列小說那些固有印象和也就僅僅限于搜索百科以后佯裝自己深入了解小說而在評(píng)論區(qū)的大放厥詞讓我感受到了仿佛評(píng)論區(qū)已經(jīng)變成了大家宣泄情緒的平臺(tái)。那么我就發(fā)出這篇我作為游戲和原著黨對(duì)于劇情的評(píng)價(jià)和對(duì)比。我希望我對(duì)于在葉奈法方面劇情的了解讓您知道，原著黨在看到電視劇后那種復(fù)雜的心路歷程。在您的心中，葉奈法僅僅是“力量 美貌 享樂”恐怕無法解釋為什么后來她在x（不想劇透）的刑具上那種堅(jiān)毅而且仍然不乏對(duì)那些人給予言語上的諷刺，他們想讓葉奈法痛苦來暴露希瑞位置但是她卻只想念著杰洛特導(dǎo)致杰洛特被迫躺槍。

您這種假裝高貴中立，拉一派打一派，說什么“游戲黨現(xiàn)在寬容多了，希望小說黨可以學(xué)習(xí)”，仿佛自己有限的認(rèn)知可以成為判斷誰好誰壞。在您的想法中，貌似國人成為了充滿偏見的存在，殊不知海外犀利的吐槽人員配角的也有很多，原著黨無論國內(nèi)國外都是雷池的存在。多看看爛番茄等等評(píng)價(jià)再大放厥詞會(huì)好很多，而不是意識(shí)流在評(píng)論。

當(dāng)然我想表達(dá)一下我的看法，我本質(zhì)上還是對(duì)這部獵魔人感官不錯(cuò)，特別是大超本身不錯(cuò)的演技，而他也是很早就拜讀過獵魔人這部小說，可以說是非常入神了，這也側(cè)面說明某些人單純把獵魔人變成冷門小說并把功勞歸于cdpr和奈飛的無知言論。

等我想再到更多再加吧，第一次寫觀后感，熬夜有點(diǎn)困了，謝謝ww

23/12/2021 06:08

改編的垃圾，這劇情真他媽惡心

真他媽無語炸了，不知道為什么小說寫的那么好為什么還要改編？是覺得自己功底比原著好嗎？就特么改編如果能看就算了，把杰洛特設(shè)計(jì)的這么傻逼，杰洛特那么多兄弟，從小到大，讓杰洛特看著死去的兄弟還特么想著救希里， 從原著到游戲，希里這條線一直都是重點(diǎn)中的重點(diǎn)，但是劇中的希里線，屬實(shí)垃圾的看到就想吐，鏡頭一轉(zhuǎn)切到希里就特么惡心。老子的女兒被塑造的這么惡心，說著尊重原創(chuàng)，結(jié)果還特么改編。

Fuck it. I decided to compile a list of every change between Season 2 and Blood of Elves

Heavy spoilers for the books and Season 2!

\---------------------------------------------------------------

This is not all-encompassing. I'll forget some changes--Heaven knows the writers made enough changes. I'll also preface this by saying: This isn't a commentary on the quality of the season itself. It is simply a collection of the differences between the novel and the show.

**Characters**

* Voleth Meir is not in the books. Completely new character.

* Geralt wouldn't use Ciri as bait in the books. Nor did he.

* Ciri is never possessed by a witch.

* Yennefer does not lose her magic in the books.

* Yennefer never considers sacrificing Ciri for power. Nor does the opportunity ever arise.

* Yennefer is not captured by Niilfgard in the books.

* Instead, she is blinded following Sodden after taking a fireball to the face from Fringilla. She then spends lots of time in recovery, then--on Dijkstra's orders--tails and saves Dandelion from Rience.

* No one ever thinks she's dead in the books either (Geralt worries that she died after Sodden, if I recall, but finds out rather quickly she's still out there after talking to Triss at the Sodden memorial)

* Later in the series (Post Time of Contempt/Late Season 3 or early Season 4 by comparison), people suspect Yennefer of being a Nilfgaardian spy. But at no point does anyone suspect her of being a spy following Sodden.

* The Stregobor stuff isn't a thing in the books. He's there, but plays no important role.

* Vessemir wouldn't try to use Ciri's blood to create more witchers in the books. Nor would he ever allow Ciri to undergo the Trial. Nor would he let Eskel bring a bunch of hookers to Kaer Morhen

* In the books, Dandelion is actively working with Djikstra and the Redanian Secret Service. ~~This is removed in the show~~ It is implied that Djikstra is funding Dandelion's sandpiper activities, though Dandelion doesn't seem to be aware of who he is working with. This is speculative on my part though.

* Also in the books, Dandelion is not nearly as comedic as he was in Season 2. He is funny, but they seemed to lean into that aspect of him for Season 2.

* This is more my interpretation, but in the books, Dandelion is far wittier than he is in the show. He certainly doesn't come across as the type to talk to rats in the book.

* Djikstra is not a rambling drunk in the books (although I didn't find that to be a bad change. It was pretty interesting IMO).

* I don't believe Istredd even appears in Blood of Elves

* Francesa Findabar is *not* with the Scoia'tael in the books. By this, I mean she's not in the field with them, acting as their leader.

* She is a member of the Brotherhood of Sorcerers, though she does harbor sympathies for their cause and occasionally meets with Scoia'tel leaders (Filavandrel, as an example). This relationship becomes relevant when she aids Niilfgaard during the Coup at Thanned

* Fringilla Vigo does not become de facto leader of Cintra in the books. Instead, she fucks off to Niilfgard

* Cahir is not captured by the Brotherhood following Sodden in the books. I don't even recall if he was at Sodden. As far as I recall, he traveled back to Niilfgard following the Fall of Cintra, and was imprisoned for failing to capture Ciri. We don't see him again for another two books after Sodden.

* His execution plot-point never happened in the books.

* Book Cahir is also not nearly as mustache-twirly-evil-villain as he is in the show. Cahir fans will know what I mean.

* Tissaia is hardly a significant character in the books.

* Rience is not a magical bounty hunter in the books. He's an almost fanatical follower of Vilgefortz in the books.

* Rience is scarred in the show and books, but in the books, it's because Yennefer uses her magic to wound him as he's interrogating Dandelion.

* Lydia Van Bredevoort does not develop her scars from sniffing a vial of elder blood in the books. Instead, her scars are a result of magical experimentation on Vilgefortz' orders, and her wounds are hidden with an illusion.

* Eskel is not turned into a Leshen and then killed (as far as we know. He's not in the books for long.)

* Vilgefortz and Tissaia are not a romantic thing, as far as I could tell. Nor are they really even partners. Vilgefortz is also the genuine champion of Sodden in the books. He does this to gain more authority in the Brotherhood.

* Vilgy is also way stronger and smarter in the books then how he is depicted in the show. Also, Vilgy never says his classic line. This is a cardinal sin, imo.

* Nenekke is an old and religious lady. She doesn't go around dropping f-bombs in the books.

* Emhyr kept the fact that Ciri was his daughter a big secret in the books. Understandable, given his plans for her (**cough** Imperial Incest **cough**)

* Jarre in the books is a bit of a geek, who is very clearly awkward around girls, and has a crush on Ciri. But he's also smart, and good-intentioned. The show reduces him to a dick joke.

**Plot Points**

* Except for Ciri's training, there is not a single fight at Kaer Morhen. Never. There is no Leshen, nor is there the centipede thing with the claws. There is no possession.

* There are only four witchers at Kaer Morhen (Vessemir, Eskel, Lambert, and Coen)

* At Kaer Morhen, Ciri trains and exercises. Eventually, Triss arrives (on Geralt's request) and instructs Ciri on the basics of magic, as well as the Elder language.

* The plot point with Ciri's blood being able to make more witchers is not in the books.

* Vesemir never collects her blood either. The thought of making more witchers is only ever entertained in the context of Ciri being raised as a girl vs. being raised as a witcher. But the mutagenic process itself/Trial of Grasses is never brought up.

* In the book, Triss travels with Ciri and Geralt to the Temple. In the show, she doesn't. We don't see her get sick.

* On the path to the Temple is when they run into Yarpen Zigrin again. This doesn't happen in the show. As a result, Ciri doesn't visit Shaerrawedd, and there is no fight with the Scoia'tael.

* There is no fight at Melitele's Temple in the books. Never.

* Yennefer does not travel to the Temple to kidnap Ciri and sacrifice her in the books.

* In the books, Ciri and Yennefer stay at the temple for a while. Ciri learns more magic.

* Yennefer is invited to the temple by Geralt after Geralt has already left. See the 'Dear Friend,' bullet point further down.

* There is no reunion between Geralt and Yennefer in Blood of Elves. They reunite outside Gors Velen in the next book.

* In the books, Rience does not find Ciri at the Temple. Instead, Geralt leaves Ciri in Nenekke's care to find Rience at Oxenfurt.

* There is no Shani in the show. >:(

* Phillipa does not help Geralt find Rience, nor does she help Rience escape: as she does in the books.

* In fact, Rience doesn't meet Ciri till the Time of Contempt, which is the next book following Blood of Elves.

* Dandelion doesn't sing at a tavern in Oxenfurt. He sings at Bleobheris, a sacred tree.

* His Sandpiper plot is not a thing in the books.

* Dandelion is not arrested in the books.

* The elf and Cintra plot is not in the books.

* There is a non-human uprising in the North in the books, led by the Scoia'tael, but they are not given Cintra as a place of refuge by the Niilfgardians. Instead, Niilfgard is suspected of funding and arming them behind the scenes to stoke instability in the North.

* Francesca never gets pregnant. Nor does Emhyr commit infanticide against an elven baby in the books.

* The notion that a pure-blooded elf hasn't been born in decades is also a Netflix invention. Elves have a much smaller window of time to get pregnant, but it still happens in the books. Avallach and Geralt talk about this in Tower of Swallow.

* The magical politics is a thing in the books, but is very different from the magical politics in the show. Stregobor does not interrogate or harm Yennefer, and neither do Tissaia/Vilgy use that as an excuse to seize Council seats.

* Instead, the magical politics in the book are concerned with the growing distrust between the Kings and their magical advisors

* The meeting of the Kings at the end of Season 2 is the meeting of the Kings in BoE that puts the Mages on edge, and is used to justify the Conclave in Time of Contempt. However, Tissaia is at the King's meeting in the show, which is not the case in the book. No mages were invited to the meeting in the books.

* When the Kings of the North meet, they do conclude it best to kill Ciri--so as to prevent her falling into Emhyr's hands (they don't want him to have a legitimate claim to the Cintran throne). However, the show cut the King's talk of war with Niilfgaard.

* In the books, they believe a quick strike across the Yaruga could recapture Cintra, and deal a blow to the South. This conversation paves the way for the Second Great War, but does not happen in the show.

* The show also leaves out the politics regarding Cintra's throne. Cordhingrer is visited by Geralt in the books, and they develop a plot to--essentially-- smear Calanthe's name and ruin her claim to the Cintrant throne, thus making Ciri's claim to the throne illegitimate. Thus, protecting her from the kings who want her dead for her political power.

* Again, the Voleth Meir plot is not in the books at all. Instead, Blood of Elves focuses on Ciri's training and planting the seeds for future conflicts.

* I.e. the Second Great War, the Coup of Thanned, Character's motivations to capture Ciri, etc.

* The Monoliths are not a thing in the books.

* The 'Dear Friend,' bit is in reference to letters exchanged by Yennefer and Geralt while Geralt is in Oxenfurt hunting for Rience. Geralt asks Yennefer to travel to the temple to train Ciri. Again, Geralt and Yen don't actually meet though.

* In the books, Niilfgardians are depicted as something more akin to the Romans or English (Highly centralized government with progressive and aristocratic traditions and legal codes). In the books, they are not religious zealots. Though they are also not necessarily 'good' either.

* Yennefer and Cahir never have a team-up in the books.

* Tissaia does not recommend that Ciri be captured, nor does she suggest that anyone protecting her be captured as well. In fact, Tissaia's role in the show is dramatically overblown.

* Ciri is not with Geralt when he meets Nivellen.

* Istredd does not meet with Cordringer and Fenn in the books. Geralt does meet them to find information about Rience and Ciri.

It's not an exaggeration to say that the *majority* of this season is different from the books. And not just sort of different, but drastically different. Hell, the last four or five episodes are fictitious (relative to the book canon (yes I know it's all fiction, please stop reminding me)) in nearly every way. At this point, I'm not certain where the story will go. For example, how will the Coup play out on Thanedd if Ciri won't be able to attend it? And if Ciri isn't at Aretuza for the Coup, then how will she be warped to the desert? And if she isn't separated from Geralt and Yennefer, then how will she meet up with the Rats?

Obviously, they can still work these plots in, or at least, work in the *effects* of these plots, but the story will take a drastically different turn than the one the book tells.

Note that this isn't necessarily a good or a bad thing, so long as it's done well. But there has to come a point when the adaptation is so drastically different from the source material, that I start to wonder whether it's truly an adaptation, or if it's a reimagining.

第一季最后，出人意料得把巫師故事原本的史詩感、傳奇性拍了出來，這一季開篇也有很大的進(jìn)步，就在我以為可以延續(xù)下去的時(shí)候：糟糕至極的改編，又莫明其妙得把大量應(yīng)該慢慢說清楚的故事冗雜在了后半段，還把咱們大名鼎鼎的布拉維坎屠夫、白狼、利維亞的杰洛特拍得肉麻話滿天，獵魔人原本對(duì)情緒的壓抑、深沉雄厚的情感以及冷靜的幽默恰好是他們的魅力。 原作的迷人之處，本該是用一個(gè)個(gè)充斥幽秘、用魔法與鮮血跟幽暗森林打交道的冒險(xiǎn)經(jīng)歷，所給觀眾帶來的代入感，以及用幾位人物復(fù)雜的情感、成長故事來貫穿了整個(gè)大陸的歷史，所帶來的厚重感，可惜這些都被劇里像被鞭子抽一樣的劇情推動(dòng)毀掉了。 原作中，正如geralt的信條一樣，他不愿踏入歷史漩渦，所以永遠(yuǎn)是以他的故事為主，著力點(diǎn)在充滿怪物的小道上，但同時(shí)又如他總是不自覺已經(jīng)踏入了漩渦一樣，他是這片大陸歷史推動(dòng)的重要一環(huán)，大故事就被側(cè)面渲染了出來。相比冰與火之歌，巫師不愿正面描述權(quán)力的博弈，geralt犀利干脆、洞悉萬物，但也是個(gè)粗人、享受在沼澤地里與野獸廝殺，遠(yuǎn)沒那個(gè)耐心染指政治，他是個(gè)傳奇、但同樣是個(gè)小人物。

其實(shí)巫師拍得好，遠(yuǎn)比權(quán)游吸引人(其實(shí)第一季后半段，第二季前半段，路子已經(jīng)走對(duì)了，并且非常精彩：個(gè)體的故事、命運(yùn)的交匯、歷史的推動(dòng)，也是原著的玩法。但其他部分，不知道是沒錢了，還是編劇腦子抽了，或是單純沒耐心拍了，非常糟糕得添油加醋、直白得敘述各種政治事件，還把這么多的概念和人物全盤托出，哪怕對(duì)我這種看過小說、玩了好幾遍游戲的觀眾來說，也非常不友好)。 波蘭人可是把巫師當(dāng)國寶，能不能不要暴殄天物呀。

就問奇不奇怪，第一季里金發(fā)金眉那么仙，第二季頂著金發(fā)結(jié)果一雙粗黑眉真的不違和嗎？？？我仙氣靈動(dòng)的希瑞怎么變憨憨了？

剛看了第一季，確實(shí)是原著里提到的真人真事…但是為什么大家都演得這么的尷尬呢，小希瑞一點(diǎn)都沒有原著里的活潑靈動(dòng)了，鏡頭剪輯也很生硬，讓人看不出前因后果來，真的不知道為啥網(wǎng)飛不能忠實(shí)于原著，其實(shí)在7部書中，最精華的部分就是前兩部中的短篇，網(wǎng)飛非但沒有拍好，還無中生有了不少內(nèi)容……剛看完原著真的覺得混亂得不行

1. 啊總算不是多條時(shí)間線故事線穿插進(jìn)行了！原本我以為是編劇終于悔改了，后來意識(shí)到是因?yàn)檫@一季原創(chuàng)天馬行空劇情太多，編劇如果還敢打亂時(shí)間線剪來剪去的，那真的沒人能看懂了==

2. 最后 恩希爾 出來的時(shí)候我都呆掉了，這尼瑪是什么頹廢暗黑霸道帝王攻，說好的中年油膩鬼*父呢，相比小說也就開了10級(jí)美顏吧。說好的小成本渣劇，里面的女性角色一個(gè)個(gè)丑到哭，為啥男性角色都帥到讓人懷疑片酬呢？嘛總之感覺第三季可以的，而且我有預(yù)感會(huì)有一大批沒有節(jié)操的同人女去嗑 白狼*白火這對(duì)cp的，就仔細(xì)想想確實(shí)也很帶感就是了！

3. 編劇把鬼*父線砍了，嗯挺好的，看原著我就覺得這條線太重口了，就魔法世界也吃不消啊。

4. 特莉絲這季是換了化妝師還是瘦身成功了之類的，顏值蹭蹭蹭上漲了不少。然而和游戲里比起來還是差了一大截。但是我覺得我這里能勉強(qiáng)接受了吧，畢竟我本來就是走葉奈法線的，而且巫師2里我也選擇沒救她，最后趕到廣場發(fā)現(xiàn)她被雷索救了，那場面一度十分尷尬==

5. 堪稱本劇最大雷點(diǎn)的 芙林吉拉 還是沒換人，而且本季她的支線劇情多到逆天，竟然和原著第一美女的精靈女王戲份平起平坐了？目測第三季她劇情還是會(huì)多到發(fā)指，希望編劇魔改改大一點(diǎn)，把白狼和她原著在陶森特那段高抬貴手給刪了吧，我實(shí)在是不忍心看到這版人比花嬌的白狼被辣手摧花啊。

6. 菲利帕那個(gè)女演員很驚艷啊！不知道為啥就最后一集給了個(gè)鏡頭就切了？她第三季應(yīng)該很多戲分吧?。ó吘顾暮０嘶牡谝粩囀汗髯樱┤缓缶褪?Dijkstra 演員還是太瘦，沒有達(dá)到原著里那個(gè)海豹的形容。拉多維德五世有點(diǎn)帥過頭不夠瘋逼，沒啥意思。還是游戲里那個(gè)黑演員朋克青年比較帶感。

7. 據(jù)說第二季收視率還不錯(cuò)？那我就敲碗坐等第三季了==